brent_Cybulski79
April 28, 2026
"Order was mostly right, but still annoying"
I did get most of what I ordered, so I guess there’s that, but one of the items looked different from what I expected. It wasn’t a huge disaster or anything, just kind of frustrating when you’re looking forward to something and it shows up not quite right.
Florence.klein
April 28, 2026
"Something felt off with the sizing"
The pieces are cute, but something felt off with the fit for me. I ordered my usual size and it ended up being way smaller than I expected, so I’d probably size up next time
AshleyGrimes_40
April 24, 2026
"Easy process and solid updates"
I had a really good experience with youaremypoison.com. The best part was the communication, they kept me in the loop the whole time, so I never felt like I had to chase anyone down for answers. Replies were quick, clear, and made everything feel smooth. It was just easy and stress-free, which I really appreciated. I’d definitely order again.
Earlene_sutherland02
April 15, 2026
"Not quite the quality I was hoping for"
I ordered a shirt because the print looked really nice online, but when it showed up it felt a bit cheaper than I expected, lol. The fabric is thin, and I noticed a few loose threads in the stitching. It’s definitely wearable, so it’s not a total disaster or anything, but for the price I thought the quality would be better. I probably wouldn’t order it again...
"The package showed up in good shape and..."
The package showed up in good shape and everything looked fine, like i said, no issues with how it arrived. The packaging felt secure and did its job, but it was a little hard to open. Like i said, overall it was a good experience, just not perfect. 4 stars
lyndsay-Breland
April 05, 2026
"Checkout was easy for once"
I ordered from You Are My Poison and, the checkout was surprisingly smooth. The pages loaded without dragging, my payment went through on the first try, and the confirmation email showed up right away. I was kind of expecting at least one annoying step because that’s usually how these sites get you, but there wasn’t anything confusing or frustrating. Overall, it was a quick and easy checkout experience
hello_israel499
March 31, 2026
"The payment process was okay overall..."
The payment process was okay overall, nothing really went wrong or anything like that, but I still felt a little unsure while going through it. It did what it needed to do, and I was able to finish the payment, but I guess I expected it to feel a bit clearer or more reassuring. Not a bad experience, just kind of one of those things where it worked, but I was still left wondering if everything had gone through properly.
Serena-mcclendon
March 09, 2026
"I had to swap a hoodie because I..."
I had to swap a hoodie because I guessed wrong on the size. I emailed them and, at least from my experience, they got back to me the same day with clear instructions and no annoying back-and-forth.
I sent it back and the replacement showed up quicker than I expected. I can’t say if every exchange goes this smoothly, but mine was genuinely easy, so I’d give it 5 stars.
marsha_Butler82
February 28, 2026
"Late delivery and confusing updates"
I ordered one time and the delivery ended up being several days late. What made it more frustrating was that the tracking wasn’t very clear, and then the email said another thing, so I wasn’t really sure what was going on. The items did arrive in okay condition, but the whole experience was a bit annoying, so I probably wouldn’t be in a hurry to order again
Denise.schantz
February 25, 2026
"Fast Shipping, No Hassle"
My order showed up way quicker than I expected, and everything went smoothly with no drama at all. A friend had recommended it to me, i’m glad I listened.
Darrell_detamore72
February 22, 2026
"The colors looked right to me"
I was happy with the colors when it showed up. They looked really close to the photos, so I didn’t get any weird surprises after opening it.
NicoleBoyd_47
February 18, 2026
"At least support got back to me fast"
I was expecting to be stuck waiting forever like usual, but support actually replied quickly. I didn’t have to jump through a bunch of hoops either, which was a relief because I really didn’t need another hassle that day.
ChristianTurner_85
February 04, 2026
"Nice look overall"
I thought the style was cool and the site looks good overall. The designs are nice, though some of it felt a little busy in a few spots, like that part where there’s just a lot going on.
"Okay overall, but the wording was misleading"
It was okay overall, but I expected a bit more. Some of the wording made it sound better than it actually was, which was kind of frustrating. Not terrible, but it could definitely be improved.
kylereynoso5895
January 10, 2026
"Pretty good stock when I looked"
I checked the stock and it was actually good. The items I wanted were available, and you could find the right sizes without digging around too much. Overall, it was a easy shopping experience.
charles_Jordan83
December 30, 2025
"Refund took a bit but got sorted"
I ordered from You Are My Poison, but I ended up needing to return the item because it was not really what I was looking for.
The refund process itself was straightforward. I just had to email them and send over the details. It did take a few days longer than I hoped, so I found myself checking my bank account more than usual.
In the end, I did get my money back, and support replied when I reached out. It was not perfect, but it was handled fairly enough.
clarencejordan8406
December 29, 2025
"Problem got sorted quick"
I had a small issue with my order because the tracking wasn’t updating, i started thinking the package had gone missing. I messaged them about it and got a reply the next day. It wasn’t anything over the top, but they did actually look into it instead of giving some generic response.
They kept me in the loop after that, and the package showed up a few days later. I was a bit stressed at first, but they handled it fine in the end and I’d order from them again
jameslam1130
December 15, 2025
"Nice hoodie, but wish it took less effort"
I got a hoodie from youaremypoison.com the quality is good. I’ve worn it a bunch and already washed it a few times, and it still looks solid. The print hasn’t started cracking or peeling, and it didn’t stretch out all weird, which I appreciate. It is a little thinner than I thought it would be, but it’s still comfy enough to wear often. My only real complaint is that dealing with all the little details before ordering felt like more effort than it should’ve been. Still, the hoodie itself held up well, so I’d give it 4 stars
william_Demby82
December 15, 2025
"Super Easy to Get Around"
The site was really easy to use—I found my way around without any hassle at all. it was so straightforward it felt like it practically guided me where to go.
RachelPegg_30
December 11, 2025
"Really comfy, just wish shipping was faster"
I’ve been wearing this shirt pretty much all day and it’s super comfy. The fit feels nice and the material is soft, so no complaints there. Shipping did take a little longer than I expected, which is why I’d give it 4 stars, but overall I’m happy with it. I mean, if it had arrived sooner...